(414) 921-1945

dan@defensewisconsin.com

  • Home
  • About Us
  • Areas of Practice
    • OWI / Drunk Driving
    • Drug Crimes
    • Domestic Violence
    • White Collar / Business Offenses
    • Campus Discipline
    • Federal Crimes
    • Traffic and Municipal Offenses
    • Pre-charge Representation
  • Legal Updates
  • In The News
  • Contact Us
  • Home
  • About Us
  • Areas of Practice
    • OWI / Drunk Driving
    • Drug Crimes
    • Domestic Violence
    • White Collar / Business Offenses
    • Campus Discipline
    • Federal Crimes
    • Traffic and Municipal Offenses
    • Pre-charge Representation
  • Legal Updates
  • In The News
  • Contact Us

Each “element of a crime” matters

Posted:
August 4th, 2012

Tags:
Criminal Defense, Insider Trading, Insider Trading Defense, White Collar Crime, White Collar Defense

Every criminal offense has a series of “elements” or facts that the government must prove beyond a reasonable doubt.  A strong defense sometimes consists of an attack on just a single element of the crime.

In a recent dismissal of an SEC action for insider trading out of the Northern District of Illinois, the district court pointed out this important, but sometimes forgotten point: no matter what the crime, no matter what the implausible story an accused gives for his or her actions, the government must prove each and every element of an alleged offense.[1]

In the case, a Spanish investor made an extraordinarily “lucky” bet on the future price of an American publically traded company.  Within days of buying a large number of call options, the company’s stock jumped on news of a possible acquisition.  The investor’s options increased in value by over 1000%.

The investor provided the SEC with a dubious explanation of his “luck”: he’d never traded in the industry before, never traded options, cited research that was released after his purchase to explain his investment decision, and offered a far different, technical explanation much later in the case.  Further, the investor threw away one of his computers and “scrubbed” the hard drive of another used to make the trades.  Further still, another Madrid-based trader made similar trades and admitted culpability in the matter.

This evidence of insider trading, though circumstantial (i.e. indirect) seems very persuasive.  However, the SEC could provide no evidence that the investor had “material non-public information obtained from an insider,” elements needed to prove the offense.  Without knowing or having had contact with an insider, the court determined there was no way the government could prove the investor obtained information from an insider.  In other words, the government missed an element of the offense, the facts of “obtained from an insider” could not be proven.

Sometimes the government’s most “slam dunk” cases are the ones where they miss an element. A competent defense attorney will take care to make sure the government always proves each and every element of a crime.


[1] SEC v. Sanchez, Dist. Court, ND Illinois 2011, No. 10 CV 5268.  (This case involved  a civil SEC action, but the lesson of proving each element remains the same as though it were a criminal offense).


  • Criminal Defense
  • Insider Trading
  • Insider Trading Defense
  • White Collar Crime
  • White Collar Defense

Share This Post

  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • Dribble
  • Google Plus
  • Behance

About

Related Posts

Attorney Adams appears in PBS documentary

Attorney Adams appears in PBS documentary

May 10th, 2016
Defending Len Bias cases in Wisconsin

Defending Len Bias cases in Wisconsin

March 22nd, 2016

Contact Info

1200 E. Capitol Drive, Suite 360, Milwaukee, WI 53211

(414) 921-1945
Please call to talk to Dan anytime, 24/7/365

dan@defensewisconsin.com

Free Consultation *

Name*

E-mail*

Popular Posts

Fighting a criminal possession charge in Wisconsin
one comment
Penalties for Possession of Marijuana Still Serious in Wisconsin
one comment
Seeking a diversion or deferred prosecution agreement for a Wisconsin drug offense
one comment
  • A Focus on Drug Overdose Homicide Cases
  • About Us
  • Areas of Practice
    • OWI / Drunk Driving
    • Drug Crimes
    • Domestic Violence
    • White Collar / Business Offenses
    • Campus Discipline
    • Federal Crimes
    • Traffic and Municipal Offenses
    • Pre-charge Representation
  • Common Offenses – Plea Form
  • Contact Us
  • Drug Offense – Plea Form
  • Home
  • Legal Updates
  • OWI – Plea Form
  • Payments
  • Text a Ticket

Copyright © 2016 Adams Law Group, LLC. All rights reserved.

* Consultations are discussions to determine whether you wish to retain Adams Laaw Group, LLC and whether we agree to represent you. A consultation does not result in legal advice and does not create an attorney-client relationship.